Skip to main content

Green AI, a reality or Green Washing?

 


In this blog post, I will summarise the main findings of a recent paper titled "A Systematic Review of Green AI" by Verdecchia et al.. The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the research field of Green AI, which aims to reduce the carbon footprint of AI models and systems. The paper analyzes 98 primary studies on Green AI published between 2016 and 2021, and identifies different patterns and trends in the literature.

A definition of Green AI. From the results regarding how the term “Green AI” is used in the literature a clear picture emerges. Most Green AI studies consider Green AI as exclusively related to energy efficiency. Only fewer studies examine the influence of AI on greenhouse gas emissions (𝐢𝑂2), and an even minor fraction examines the holistic impact that AI has on the natural environment.

The paper categorises the Green AI studies into four main types: position papers, observational studies, solution papers, and tool papers. Position papers propose new definitions, frameworks, or challenges for Green AI. Observational studies measure or estimate the energy consumption or carbon emissions of AI models or systems. Solution papers propose new methods, techniques, or algorithms to improve the environmental sustainability of AI models or systems. Tool papers present new tools or frameworks to support Green AI research or practice.

The paper also analyses the Green AI studies according to different dimensions, such as the target phase (training, inference, or deployment), the target algorithm (algorithm-agnostic, neural networks, or others), the target data type (image, text, speech, or others), the research strategy (laboratory experiments, case studies, surveys, or others), the reported energy savings (percentage of energy reduction compared to a baseline), the industrial involvement (whether the study involves industrial partners or targets industrial readers), and the tool provisioning (whether the study provides a tool or framework for Green AI).

The paper reports several interesting findings from the analysis. For example:

  • The topic of Green AI experienced a considerable growth from 2020 onward, with more than half of the primary studies published in 2020 and 2021.
  • Most studies focus on monitoring AI model footprint, tuning hyperparameters to improve model sustainability, or benchmarking models.
  • Most papers focus on the training phase, are algorithm-agnostic or study neural networks, and use image data.
  • Laboratory experiments are the most common research strategy, followed by case studies and surveys.
  • Reported Green AI energy savings go up to 115%, with savings over 50% being rather common.
  • Industrial parties are involved in Green AI studies, albeit most target academic readers.
  • Green AI tool provisioning is scarce, with only 10% of the primary studies providing a tool or framework for Green AI.

The paper concludes that the Green AI research field has reached a considerable level of maturity, and suggests that future research should adopt other Green AI research strategies, such as conducting more case studies and surveys, and porting the promising academic results to industrial practice.

I hope this blog post has given you a brief overview of the paper "A Systematic Review of Green AI" by Verdecchia et al.. If you are interested in learning more about Green AI research and practice, I recommend you to read the full paper and check out some of the references  it cites.

: Verdecchia et al., "A Systematic Review of Green AI", arXiv:2301.11047 [cs.AI], 2023

: Strubell et al., "Energy and Policy Considerations for Deep Learning in NLP", ACL 2019

: Schwartz et al., "Green AI", Communications of ACM 2020

What seems clear from the paper is that given a lot more focus the companies developing AI could save a considerable amount of resources in both the development and deployment stages. One of the concluding remarks of the paper it is noted:' The potential of Green AI cannot be disregarded: the majority of publications show significant energy savings, up to 115%, at little or no cost in accuracy.'

However, until there is a consistent use of terminology and understanding of the term Green AI, that goes beyond the associated energy consumption, it is not a term of much utility. 


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The AI Dilemma and "Gollem-Class" AIs

From the Center for Humane Technology Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin discuss how existing A.I. capabilities already pose catastrophic risks to a functional society, how A.I. companies are caught in a race to deploy as quickly as possible without adequate safety measures, and what it would mean to upgrade our institutions to a post-A.I. world. This presentation is from a private gathering in San Francisco on March 9th with leading technologists and decision-makers with the ability to influence the future of large-language model A.I.s. This presentation was given before the launch of GPT-4. One of the more astute critics of the tech industry, Tristan Harris, who has recently given stark evidence to Congress. It is worth watching both of these videos, as the Congress address gives a context of PR industry and it's regular abuses. "If we understand the mechanisms and motives of the group mind, it is now possible to control and regiment the masses according to our will without their...
Post a Comment
Read more

CRM and AI?

Artificial intelligence (AI) can be used in a CRM system to enhance customer service, sales performance, and marketing strategies. Here are some examples of how AI can be applied in a CRM: - AI can enable natural language processing and voice input, such as Siri or Alexa, to allow a CRM system to answer customer queries, solve their problems, and even identify new opportunities for the sales team. Some AI-driven CRM systems can even multitask to handle all these functions and more. - AI can help with sales forecasting by analysing historical data, customer behaviour, and market trends. This can help the sales team make more accurate predictions for future sales figures and determine a success metric. - AI can assist with lead management by automating the process of qualifying and nurturing prospects. It can use chatbots and email bots to understand leads' needs and inform the sales team to improve their performance. With insights gained from these bots, companies can optimise their...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Network Analysis Tool to help identify structural gaps

  InfraNodus is a web-based open source tool and method for generating insight from any text or discourse using text network analysis. The byline on the website states, 'Get an overview of any discourse, reveal the blind spots, enhance your perspective.' which, whilst accurate does little to summarise the potential of such a tool. Watching the introduction helps. Its capabilities include representing any text as a network and identifying the most influential words in a discourse based on the terms' co-occurrence, providing text network visualization and analysis live as new data is added, offering discourse structure analysis to measure the level of bias in discourse and identify structural gaps in discourse, and being available via an API to be used in conjunction with other text mining and analysis software. The white paper, ' Generating Insight Using Text Network Analysis ' concludes:  'The tool is currently used by researchers, marketing professionals, stude...
Post a Comment
Read more