Skip to main content

You can fool some of the people all of the time: AIs and deception

 


Two papers that each consider trust and AIs are of interest, the first is 'Suspicious Minds: The Problem of Trust and Conversational Agents' by Jonas Ivarsson, University of Gothenburg. The second by Rogers and Webber, "Lying About Lying: Examining Trust Repair Strategies After Robot Deception in a High Stakes HRI Scenario". 

Artificial intelligence is getting so good at talking that it's hard to tell the difference between humans and machines.

It can now be difficult to know who you're talking to. 'Consequently, the ‘Turing test’ has moved from the laboratory into the wild', as Ivarsson states, If you think you're talking to a human, but it's actually a machine, you might share personal information that you wouldn't want to share with a machine.

This is also a problem because it can erode trust in human-to-human interactions. If people can't tell the difference between humans and machines, they might start to distrust each other.

'Therefore, this study concludes that the proliferation of conversational systems, fueled by artificial intelligence, may have unintended consequences, including impacts on human–human interactions.'

The issues that Ivarsson explored are only exacerbated by the topic of the second paper, as Webber states in this:

"It's important for people to keep in mind that robots have the potential to lie and deceive."

This study looked at how humans react when a robot lies to them. The study found that people are more likely to change their behavior if they are told that the robot is lying, and that an apology without acknowledging intentional deception is the best way to repair trust.

Designers and policy makers need to consider GPTs current abilities to deceive and what the implications are, even before we get to robots. 

In two to three years time, as manufacturers imbue more and more of your everyday technology with AI 'assistants', your phones, cars, TVs, etcetera, and you realise that they are lying to you, what will the human response be? Will their apologies be sufficient?





Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Whispers in the Machine: Why Prompt Injection Remains a Persistent Threat to LLMs

 Large Language Models (LLMs) are rapidly transforming how we interact with technology, offering incredible potential for tasks ranging from content creation to complex analysis. However, as these powerful tools become more integrated into our lives, so too do the novel security challenges they present. Among these, prompt injection attacks stand out as a particularly persistent and evolving threat. These attacks, as one recent paper (Safety at Scale: A Comprehensive Survey of Large Model Safety https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.05206) highlights, involve subtly manipulating LLMs to deviate from their intended purpose, and the methods are becoming increasingly sophisticated. At its core, a prompt injection attack involves embedding a malicious instruction within an otherwise normal request, tricking the LLM into producing unintended – and potentially harmful – outputs. Think of it as slipping a secret, contradictory instruction into a seemingly harmless conversation. What makes prompt inj...
Post a Comment
Read more

Podcast Soon Notice

I've been invited to make a podcast around the themes and ideas presented in this blog. More details will be announced soon. This is also your opportunity to be involved in the debate. If you have a response to any of the blog posts posted here, or consider an important issue in the debate around AGI is not being discussed, then please get in touch via the comments.  I look forward to hearing from you.
Post a Comment
Read more

The tech utopia of endless leisure time is here: goodbye jobs

  'AI eliminated nearly 4,000 jobs in May' so it's reported by hallenger, Gray & Christmas, Inc. Following on from reports by IBM et al that thousands of job cuts will occur due to AI replacement, there is no need to wait for the utopia of AI allowing humans more leisure time, as that's already here, in the form of redundancies, if we are to accept the reports findings. 'With the exception of Education, Government, Industrial Manufacturing, and Utilities, every industry has seen an increase in layoffs this year.' What's particularly notable is that it's the Tech sector that's the most affected from job cuts in the US economy: 'The Technology sector announced the most cuts in May with 22,887, for a total of 136,831 this year, up 2,939% from the 4,503 cuts announced in the same period last year. The Tech sector has now announced the most cuts for the sector since 2001, when 168,395 cuts were announced for the entire year. ' Another reason ...
Post a Comment
Read more