Skip to main content

Is an AGI even required to achieve similar results?


A Comprehensive Artificial Intelligence Services technical report model by Drexler, from 2019, seems useful to revisit at this time. Instead of focusing on the hypothetical scenario of a single superintelligent agent that surpasses human intelligence, we should, the report argues, consider the more realistic possibility of a diverse and interconnected network of AI systems that provide various services for different tasks and domains. They call this approach Comprehensive AI Services (CAIS).

The main advantages of CAIS are that it avoids some of the conceptual and technical difficulties of defining and measuring intelligence, and that it allows for a more fine-grained and flexible analysis of the potential benefits and risks of AI. 

It's also a good way of considering where we have arrived at, with AgentGPT's operating via Hugging Face or via AutoGPT for example. By connecting a range of Narrow AI tools to perform the tasks that they are optimised for, and having a 'manager' assign the allocation of these tasks, giving the correct prompts for each agent, this 'comprehensive' approach could provide similar results to an AGI? 

The authors of the technical report suggested that CAIS can help us better align AI systems with human values and goals, by enabling more human oversight and collaboration, and by fostering a culture of responsibility and accountability among AI developers and users. Which seems far more plausible than trying to do that with a monolithic AGI.

The authors conclude by outlining some of the open questions and challenges that CAIS poses for AI research and governance, such as how to ensure the reliability, security, and interoperability of AI services, how to balance the trade-offs between centralization and decentralization of AI systems, and how to promote ethical and social norms for AI use and development. These are questions that exist for all AI systems. 



Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Whispers in the Machine: Why Prompt Injection Remains a Persistent Threat to LLMs

 Large Language Models (LLMs) are rapidly transforming how we interact with technology, offering incredible potential for tasks ranging from content creation to complex analysis. However, as these powerful tools become more integrated into our lives, so too do the novel security challenges they present. Among these, prompt injection attacks stand out as a particularly persistent and evolving threat. These attacks, as one recent paper (Safety at Scale: A Comprehensive Survey of Large Model Safety https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.05206) highlights, involve subtly manipulating LLMs to deviate from their intended purpose, and the methods are becoming increasingly sophisticated. At its core, a prompt injection attack involves embedding a malicious instruction within an otherwise normal request, tricking the LLM into producing unintended – and potentially harmful – outputs. Think of it as slipping a secret, contradictory instruction into a seemingly harmless conversation. What makes prompt inj...
Post a Comment
Read more

Podcast Soon Notice

I've been invited to make a podcast around the themes and ideas presented in this blog. More details will be announced soon. This is also your opportunity to be involved in the debate. If you have a response to any of the blog posts posted here, or consider an important issue in the debate around AGI is not being discussed, then please get in touch via the comments.  I look forward to hearing from you.
Post a Comment
Read more

The tech utopia of endless leisure time is here: goodbye jobs

  'AI eliminated nearly 4,000 jobs in May' so it's reported by hallenger, Gray & Christmas, Inc. Following on from reports by IBM et al that thousands of job cuts will occur due to AI replacement, there is no need to wait for the utopia of AI allowing humans more leisure time, as that's already here, in the form of redundancies, if we are to accept the reports findings. 'With the exception of Education, Government, Industrial Manufacturing, and Utilities, every industry has seen an increase in layoffs this year.' What's particularly notable is that it's the Tech sector that's the most affected from job cuts in the US economy: 'The Technology sector announced the most cuts in May with 22,887, for a total of 136,831 this year, up 2,939% from the 4,503 cuts announced in the same period last year. The Tech sector has now announced the most cuts for the sector since 2001, when 168,395 cuts were announced for the entire year. ' Another reason ...
Post a Comment
Read more